The White Badger Inn

The Pillar & Ground of Truth
Nominalism, Voluntarism, & Thomism continued...

If you have not read the article entitled Catholic Protestantism, you should check it out before reading this article.

The purpose of this article (Pillar & Ground of Truth) is to emphasize that Thomistic doctrines were not suppressed by the doctrine of the Reformation.

When I speak of Thomistic doctrine, I do not point to clearly established Catholic doctrine or dogma, but rather, the idea laid down by Thomas Aquinas which attempts to comprehend Christian doctrine through a realistic & comprehensive intellectual sense. Aquinas incorporated much of Aristotle's logic into his efforts to either elucidate or simplify his Theology.

This same concept, I argue, is seen in the writings and practices of the Reformers, although we may be tempted to misinterpret their stance, since they were fighting the sensless doctrines of their time, and attempting to elevate the importance of Faith (Sola Fide).

It has been argued by some that, among the various doctrinal implications of the Reformation was the influence of Voluntarism, however I think that those who truly hold to the key doctrines of the Reformation (i.e., those who call themselves Reformed) would disagree.

For instance, Matthew Henry, when commenting on God's love for the "Gates of Zion more than all the dwellings of Jacob," says that His love was, in particular, for His "Houses of Doctrine." (Not the Voluntaristic style of Modern Evangelicals, who purport God's supposed love for all men.) Here, the distinctives of discernable doctrine are elevated and respected.

Charles Spurgeon, a definite proponent of Reformed Theology, when speaking on the same passage (Psalm 87:2) speaks of the doctrine of the Church, and how she is the Ground & Pillar of Truth. He argues that the authority of this position hinges on particular doctrines, not some voluntaristic "feeling" with no legitimate foundation.

Clearly, these are not men who would seek to root out the theological or intellectual implications of the doctrine of the Church.
It was certainly said of John Gill that there was no "greater learned man in all of England" while he lived. In "A Tercentennial Appreciation" of John Gill (Edited by Michael A.G. Haykin) it is said of Gill that he was the "doyen of High Calvinism in the transatlantic Baptist community of the eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries."

As we look at some of the highlights of Gill's theological career, we quickly realize the extent of his Intellectual prowess and the theological nuances which composed his person. For instance, if we were to peruse his extensive published works, we would immediately be made aware of his trinitarian theology, soteriological views, Baptist ecclesiology, and his use of Scripture.

Time would fail me to speak of the Puritan views of doctrine and intellectual illumination, while clearly following established Reformation Theology.

Certainly, then, it is illogical to claim that the Reformed Tradition engenders or encourages Voluntarism, but seems, indeed, to do quite the opposite.

For a defense of Gill's scholasticism, I suggest clicking this ARTICLE.